Anna Dello Russo, editor-at-large of Vogue Japan and street style celebrity, has made taking looks verbatim from the runway to real life her trademark. Some call it daring as very few humans live in a world where they can lift an entire runway look and not get carted off to a loony bin, others call it lazy–where is the creativity in styling if one just copies what they see on the runway? Jewelry designers often create a few distinct lines of jewelry for sale in retail platforms. This begs the question: Should we wear matching pieces from the same line or branch out a bit? I use Alexis Bittar as my case study here because he is a costume jewelry designer who comes up with many different lines that are quite dissimilar to each other in aesthetic. He currently has a collection inspired by Georgia O’Keefe, an ‘elements’ line that draws from nature, a modernist line, a lucite line, even a Mauritius monkey line.
My personal inclination is to go against matchy-matchy jewelry. To wear earrings, necklace and bracelet all from the same line feels very dated to me. However, I see nothing wrong with wearing many pieces from different collections of the same designer.
What Not to Do
Please don’t put an entire look together with pieces from the same line (see below). I don’t care how old or young your are, it sends the message that your look was inspired by moth balls.

Alexis Bittar, Ophelia earrings; available here.
Alexis Bittar, Ophelia necklace; available here.

Alexis Bittar, Ophelia brooch; available here.
What to do
Instead, I would pull one piece from the collection and use it as inspiration for a cohesive look that also brings in other elements. If you like the Ophelia earrings from above, perhaps pair it as follows for a much more modern take on matching jewelry by echoing similar materials or colors.
Alexis Bittar, Ophelia earrings; available here.
Alexis Bittar, liquid gold thin collar; available here.
Alexis Bittar, ripped gold cuff; available here.
Alternatively, if earrings + necklace + cuff is not your thing, try just choosing one kind of jewelry like bangles for example, and layering them for an over the top look that doesn’t weigh you down. I would wear the top two cuffs on the same arm and then the third cuff on the other arm for a little bit of asymmetry and interest.
Alexis Bittar, gold parrot cuff; available here.
Alexis Bittar, baroque hinge bracelet; available here.
Alexis Bittar, modernist gold dotted bracelet; available here.
In essence, anything that is too matchy-matchy looks terrible. However, feel free to match different aspects of your jewelry whether it’s the color, material, inspiration, or style.
Big Kiss and Bigger Diamonds,
JZP